When We Met Other Human Species

Commentaires

  1. PBS Eons

    PBS EonsIl y a 2 mois

    Some commenters have pointed out that calling Neanderthals and Denisovans “other hominin species” in this episode breaks the rules of the biological species concept (BSC), which says if two things can interbreed, then they’re the same species. Some paleoanthropologists would agree. They consider both Neanderthals and Denisovans to be subspecies of Homo sapiens, rather than separate species. Other experts would say that Neanderthals have a set of features that make them clearly distinguishable from Homo sapiens, putting them outside the range of variation we include in our species. And we hardly know the Denisovans - like we said in the video, they don’t even have a scientific name yet. The incredible thing about this is that we can even think about applying the BSC to fossils at all. The BSC is a species concept based on living organisms, and it’s only been within the last two decades or so that we’ve had the ancient DNA and the technology to test hypotheses about interbreeding in extinct groups. And it’s not the only way to define a species, either, so it will likely be a while (if ever) before anthropologists decide whether we’re a different species, subspecies, or population from the Neanderthals and Denisovans. (Darcy Shapiro, PhD, script editor)

  2. Tague Relyea

    Tague RelyeaIl y a 2 jours

    Denisovens we’re probably hot

  3. Tague Relyea

    Tague RelyeaIl y a 2 jours

    Ever hear of a fckn chiweenie? How bout a labradoodle?

  4. rh1507

    rh1507Il y a 14 jours

    It seems illogical that our species could successfully breed with a different biped species. Of course there are several variations of our species but we are all of the same species.

  5. Adela Hogarth

    Adela HogarthIl y a 16 jours

    They weren't different species. I'm a reptile handler enthusiast in Australia and there's perfect examples of one species looking so radically different, with vastly different hunting strategies, egg-clutching behaviour, and general size and appearance ... and yet they're the same species. The common carpet python and the diamond python. Both of them morelia spilota... Their personalities, colouration, hunting strategies, and even their average clutch sizes are wildly divergent. Both of them interbreed and produce fertile young. Both of them produce hybrids. That being said, in the wild they had become geographically locked into different environments with the Holocene epoch, and over thousands of generations have become very different looking and behaviourally incongruent subspecies of the whole. And these differences are worlds apart on their own, just not enough to create two distinct species. Another common example? Dogs. All of them have been carefully bred and undertaken significant animal husbandry that you can have dogs the size of your hand, to dogs that weigh as much as a person. Still the same species.

  6. ChickenFish

    ChickenFishIl y a 18 jours

    @Olav big cats can breed even hybrid ones male or female.theyre are more likely to be sterile.thats all. and species is a word used to describe compatible breeders. if 2 things can breed they are the same species

  7. Bab Manbal

    Bab ManbalIl y a 6 heures

    Homo Gaypiens

  8. matabeleman

    matabelemanIl y a 7 heures

    yudda yudda yudda

  9. F H W

    F H WIl y a 11 heures

    We are Hybrids

  10. lucyluna00

    lucyluna00Il y a 22 heures

    Ugh, eww humans, they are still terrible no matter where we evolve...but this was neat!

  11. Push Back

    Push BackIl y a jour

    "...an interbreeding event..." I'll just leave that there.

  12. Carolyn Norton

    Carolyn NortonIl y a jour

    A wonderful and informative presentation. Thank you.

  13. Faith T

    Faith TIl y a jour

    Maasai in Africa have Neanderthal DNA.

  14. Marylou Blackwell

    Marylou BlackwellIl y a 2 jours

    Neanderthals lives matter

  15. Steve's art n fun channel Stephen hall

    Steve's art n fun channel Stephen hallIl y a 2 jours

    How could u not interbreed. U like what u like.

  16. Manuel Popp

    Manuel PoppIl y a 2 jours

    If we can interbreed with them, are they even a different species? Or: Are Europeans and Asians even the same species as subsaharean Africans if they differ in particular genes and are mixed with neanderthals?

  17. Penelope Johnson

    Penelope JohnsonIl y a 2 jours

    Who were The First Ancient Cartographers?

  18. Buna

    BunaIl y a 5 heures

    Penelope Johnson did maps even exist during the time? 🤔

  19. 凃孝霖

    凃孝霖Il y a 3 jours

    I've always been curious, there's no way our ancestors could ever tell that other hominid species were separate species when they encountered each other no?

  20. Mazing Worldof Megan

    Mazing Worldof MeganIl y a 4 jours

    Do you think having one type of DNA would explain why we have different ways of thinking

  21. Mediocre

    MediocreIl y a 4 jours

    Why are the different races of humans not treated as separate sub species? They’re obviously distinct and evolved and adapted in their own different environment, I mean humans change and evolve just like every other animal

  22. Carolyn Reynolds

    Carolyn ReynoldsIl y a 4 jours

    Modern human did not migrate out of Africa. Stop connecting the wrong dots.

  23. Veronica Obiglio

    Veronica ObiglioIl y a 4 jours

    Intelligence is the difference

  24. Veronica Obiglio

    Veronica ObiglioIl y a 4 jours

    O laimos kondos

  25. Veronica Obiglio

    Veronica ObiglioIl y a 4 jours

    They couldnt speak And move the arms like us

  26. Ezekiel James

    Ezekiel JamesIl y a 4 jours

    Dude, there is no 100000000000 years.. Your evolution theory is failing and there is no solid proof of just one occurrence of it even happening.. Creation Creation Creation..

  27. Dennis Gawera

    Dennis GaweraIl y a jour

    You apparently have a double dose of Neanderthal DNA.

  28. LLO

    LLOIl y a 4 jours

    Gee humans mated with other hominids...Hell humans screw sheep and goats. I've been saying that if we were compatible it would happen based on what humans do now. I've been saying this for 30 years! Why would a human male kill a woman he can have sex with when there were VERY FEW hominids!

  29. The Garden Prophet

    The Garden ProphetIl y a 4 jours

    They probably disappeared from being hunted. Humans have quite the history of doing that.

  30. Mma Series

    Mma SeriesIl y a 4 jours

    Isnt it crazy how you can get to know so much information from the internet. I Mean our generation Are going to be so clever and have deep knowledge, only a scientist would have known thesr things 30 years ago.

  31. Tito Burney

    Tito BurneyIl y a 4 jours

    How much modern human DNA has been found in non modern human specimens. I have a theory that modern humans screwed and out screw our ancestors and cousins into extinction. Climate change a factor an well. But the fact that mitochondrial DNA was found suggest that we were sticking it to everything we could and population estimates suggest that the other humans weren't spreading their seed as prolifically. Therefore unable to keep up with our reproductive rates and falling victim to humanoid lust eventually were absorbed into the modern human species. One can also argue that were a subclass of the same species since we could successfully reproduce without producing sterile offspring. Hmmm, one to grow on.

  32. Peter Amarillo

    Peter AmarilloIl y a 4 jours

    Great video

  33. blisscick

    blisscickIl y a 5 jours

    There is to many questions

  34. Dennis Gawera

    Dennis GaweraIl y a jour

    There are too many questions. Are you a blond Neanderthal ? That's one of the questions.

  35. Beaux Dup

    Beaux DupIl y a 5 jours

    Scientist A, "hey I found a coupe bones", Scientist B "what are they from? "Scientist A "I am not sure yet, but they look like ape bones," Scientist B" just a few bones look like ape bones?" Scientist A no but there are so many easily deceived people who are willfully ignorant and ready to believe anything that they will accept this knowledge as fact! "Scientist B" oh yeah those democrats will believe anything, maybe you can convince them to sell their soul, kill their babies, worship idols, pedophiles, actors, pop singers, athletes, money, themselves, and maybe even Bernie Sanders? Scientist A, nah just the bones for now, your going too far!

  36. blisscick

    blisscickIl y a 5 jours

    So question since the Neanderthals headlong gated skulls and they were not from Africa then why did the Egyptians worship this elongated skull. Why did wrap their infants heads to make them elongated?

  37. rakification

    rakificationIl y a 5 jours

    Just to add: the narrative about the lack of Neanderthals genomes in sub Sahara Africa is not correct, because of many back migrations from Eurasia to Africa. It's obviously with the people in Eritrea and some Ethiopian folks, but also in Nigeria, South Africa etc are tribes with Eurasian ancestry DNA from breeding, especially in the last 6000 years.

  38. Ding Dong

    Ding DongIl y a 6 jours

    I dont belive all the Neanderthals and homosepians breeded together. How many times did they fight against each other. I think homosepians have been around since the Jurassic age.

  39. Jackson V

    Jackson VIl y a 6 jours

    Those holes in the top of some of the skulls were evidence that a surgery was performer to get demons out.

  40. BlackSuave44

    BlackSuave44Il y a 6 jours

    Am I the only one annoyed by him saying 'Neander TALLS'?? I'm pretty sure it's OK to include the 'h' in Neanderthals.

  41. MusicIsSoMuchFun Piano

    MusicIsSoMuchFun PianoIl y a 7 jours

    And that's why some of us can swim in the arctic ocean in winter, while others can run 4:00 miles for a marathon in the heat. The end...

  42. Brandon Castle

    Brandon CastleIl y a 7 jours

    OOOOORRRRRRRR, evolution!

  43. oldcowbb

    oldcowbbIl y a 7 jours

    imagine how bad racism will be if other hominin still exist

  44. Feiner Fug

    Feiner FugIl y a 6 jours

    That would be „speciesism“, then :-)

  45. zoky Zura

    zoky ZuraIl y a 7 jours

    Wow this videos tell you so much about whole lot of nothing.

  46. ZERO TWO Eto

    ZERO TWO EtoIl y a 8 jours

    i am not alone i got my mama

  47. Eli Amos

    Eli AmosIl y a 8 jours

    Neanderthals On Corsica Cool!!

  48. Hero4fun

    Hero4funIl y a 8 jours

    I think my neighbour is a neanderthal, he looks exactly like the description from this video. Why should I do? Should I Call the police or capture him myself, show him to the world and win a nobel price?

  49. Craig Banholzer

    Craig BanholzerIl y a 8 jours

    Is there a reason that the family tree is upside down in this presentation? At first, it seemed to represent two groups integrating in recent times.

  50. Tom Fuller

    Tom FullerIl y a 8 jours

    PBS could mess up a one naked man parade in a ghost town.

  51. sherman squires

    sherman squiresIl y a 8 jours

    Have we really discovered fossils of Neanderthals? They are found in stone, right?

  52. Skyler Arroniz

    Skyler ArronizIl y a 9 jours

    Waite so the neanderthals mated with other humanoids in Siberia so then who are their ancestors. Where they already their or did they migrate? If they where already there then this whole life stared in Africa is not completely correct

  53. Sterling Pickens

    Sterling PickensIl y a 9 jours

    Which other humanoids/hominins, besides neanderthals and denisovans, did we interbreed with ? How many different humanoids/hominins lived during the same time as us ? it seems like it's not explored, but "others" is mentioned.

  54. rationalguy

    rationalguyIl y a 10 jours

    Pretty sure I have perhaps a bit more Neanderthal admixture than many. Northern European. prominent brow ridges. receding chin. Basically a troll.

  55. Tommy Davies

    Tommy DaviesIl y a 10 jours

    we aren't the only ones there is so much complication and congregation and dilemmas all affecting the bigger picture

  56. Tom Downer

    Tom DownerIl y a 10 jours

    I wonder if, say, the Neanderthals weren't completely wiped out, that we would have still bred with them enough that we'd end up merging our species together?

  57. J. Brice

    J. BriceIl y a 10 jours

    i thought homo sapiens hunted the Neanderthals to the brink of extinction

  58. PiousMoltar

    PiousMoltarIl y a 11 jours

    "No evidence of violence" You know what humans are like right? Look at all the wars that have been fought in known history. Now throw another SPECIES of human into the mix. One that seemed to live a hunter gatherer lifestyle. Duh.

  59. Bodfishblues

    BodfishbluesIl y a 11 jours

    What about Bigfoot?

  60. A.D.Prayer

    A.D.PrayerIl y a 11 jours

    Do an updated episode about the village of pureblood Neanderthals Fountain deep in Siberia.

  61. Mimas Impersonator

    Mimas ImpersonatorIl y a 9 jours

    What?

  62. Asian Apparition

    Asian ApparitionIl y a 11 jours

    So this is the fault of our most kinky ancestors: Homo Erectus

  63. Pseudo Pulk

    Pseudo PulkIl y a 11 jours

    Otacon!

  64. Rafael Galano

    Rafael GalanoIl y a 12 jours

    What about the Homo Luzonensis found in the Philippines? Uranium dating says it's way older than those early humans from Africa.

  65. Devix

    DevixIl y a 12 jours

    BTW that Africans have NO DNA from Neanderthals MAY be wrong since we know some homo sapiens actually left Europe and returned to Africa. More research is needed here but there might be populations with Neanderthal DNA in Africa too, just FYI.

  66. Joe mama

    Joe mamaIl y a 12 jours

    I can’t lie I wish time travel was real so I could go back in time and see the first humans

  67. Sterling Archer

    Sterling ArcherIl y a 2 jours

    gummy gwyn I’m thinking of that gta5 movie with the chimps lol

  68. gummy gwyn

    gummy gwynIl y a 9 jours

    Just don't sneeze nor cough anywhere near them

  69. Ricky All Around Fisherman

    Ricky All Around FishermanIl y a 12 jours

    So are we all hybrids?

  70. drevni kocur

    drevni kocurIl y a 13 jours

    Hominins

  71. Krixx Set

    Krixx SetIl y a 13 jours

    Sub-saharan africans contain admixture from ancient hominids not found in any other human population. Given the fact they contain no neanderthal DNA this seriously calls into question the "out of africa hypothesis....

  72. Kidddkc 4100

    Kidddkc 4100Il y a 13 jours

    What about Australia?